Andrew

In "The Peanut Butter Brothers," brothers Andrew, Abraham, and Austin Petersheim navigate their family-owned business alongside the matchmaking efforts of their younger siblings. Handsome and deeply rooted in his Wisconsin Amish community, Andrew's life is disrupted when he meets Mary Coblenz, a young woman who has returned after leaving the community, pregnant and alone. As Mary works at the Honeybee Farm, she challenges Andrew's understanding of love and forgiveness, leading him to question his own beliefs and consider a future with her.