The Buggy Before the Horse

As Thanksgiving approaches, Cheryl uncovers a mystery involving a mysterious intruder who is not only sleeping in the Millers' winter buggy but also stealing food from their farmhouse cellar. Despite Naomi's wishes for hospitality, Cheryl is determined to solve the thefts plaguing Sugarcreek, especially as they escalate with a significant theft from the local gift shop. With a growing list of suspects, including a troubled foster child and various visitors in town, the urgency to identify the thief intensifies before the Millers face a more severe crime.